New York Non-Compete Agreements: When Are They Enforceable?

A healthcare worker reviews her contract before signing.

Key Takeaways

  • New York does not ban non-competes.Courts apply a reasonableness test to determine whether restrictions are enforceable.
  • The agreement’s scope matters. Duration, geographic reach, and the employer’s legitimate business interests affect enforceability.
  • Physicians face additional considerations. New York courts have enforced physician non-competes but may consider their effects on patients and the public.

Can an Employer Enforce a Non-Compete Agreement in New York?

New York does not have a law banning employee non-compete agreements. Instead, courts evaluate these restrictions under state law, considering whether they are reasonable and necessary to protect legitimate business interests.

For physicians, a non-compete may affect where you can work or whether you can open an independent practice. Reviewing your physician employment agreement before resigning or accepting another position can identify potential restrictions and inform decisions about next steps.

How Does New York Law Determine Whether a Non-Compete Is Enforceable?

New York courts generally apply a three-part test when a non-compete is challenged. A restriction must:

  • Be no broader than necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate interests
  • Avoid imposing undue hardship on the employee
  • Avoid harming the public interest

Courts also consider whether the restriction is reasonable in duration and geographic scope. The analysis depends on the agreement’s language and the circumstances surrounding the employment relationship.

An employer may have a legitimate interest in protecting trade secrets, confidential customer information, or relationships developed through the employer’s resources. However, preventing a former employee from working for any competitor may go beyond what is necessary to protect those interests.

New York courts can also partially enforce an overbroad restriction in appropriate circumstances. A court could consider whether the employer acted in good faith, whether the restriction involved overreach or coercion, and whether it can be narrowed to protect a legitimate interest.

Signing a non-compete does not automatically make it enforceable. However, physicians and other healthcare professionals should not assume that a restriction is invalid simply because it appears broad.

What Restrictions Can Affect Healthcare Professionals?

A non-compete is only one type of contractual restriction that may affect a physician leaving a job. Common restrictions include:

  • Non-compete clauses restrict certain competitive work after employment ends. Depending on the wording, they may limit where you can work or whether you can establish a competing practice.
  • Non-solicitation clauses restrict efforts to solicit specified patients, referral sources, or employees. These provisions differ from non-competes and must be evaluated according to their terms and applicable law.
  • Confidentiality provisions govern the use or disclosure of protected information, such as trade secrets and confidential business records. They should be distinguished from restrictions on using general professional knowledge and experience.
  • Notice and termination provisions establish requirements for leaving a position. Agreements may also address repayment obligations, compensation, or other financial consequences.

Review these terms together. Even if a non-compete is unenforceable, other restrictive covenants may remain in effect.

At Jackson LLP, our healthcare attorneys review physician employment contracts. We can advise you on your contract before you sign or when you are considering leaving. Contact us today for a free consultation.

Have Courts Upheld Non-Compete Agreements Against New York Physicians?

New York courts have historically enforced physician non-compete agreements when the restrictions satisfy applicable legal standards. These decisions do not mean that every physician non-compete is enforceable. Courts still examine the specific restriction and the circumstances.

For example, a restriction limited to a defined area and period may be evaluated differently from one covering a broad region. The outcome depends on the facts, not simply on the number of miles or months specified in the agreement.

Physicians planning to join another practice or open their own should review whether the proposed location or activities could violate contractual restrictions. Patient non-solicitation provisions and confidentiality obligations may also affect the transition.

What Should You Review Before Leaving a Healthcare Job?

Before resigning, accepting another position, or opening a practice, review the agreement for terms that may continue after employment ends. Pay attention to:

  • Duration and Geographic Scope: How long do restrictions last, and which locations do they cover?
  • Restricted Activities: Does the agreement prohibit all competing work or only specified activities?
  • Patient and Referral Relationships: Are there limits on soliciting patients or contacting referral sources?
  • Notice Requirements: How much advance notice must you give before leaving?
  • Financial Obligations: Could repayment requirements or other financial terms affect your departure?
  • Confidential Information: What information must remain confidential, and what rules govern practice records?

If a provision appears overly broad, do not assume you can disregard it. An employer may seek enforcement or a court order, creating uncertainty and legal expense even if the restriction is ultimately found unenforceable. Reviewing the agreement before giving notice can give you time to assess potential problems and consider your options.

Will New York Ban Non-Compete Agreements in the Future?

New York lawmakers have considered legislation in recent years that would prohibit many employee non-compete agreements. Because legislation may change, healthcare professionals should confirm the current rules before making decisions based on a particular restriction or clause.

Let Us Review Your New York Non-Compete Agreement

A non-compete can affect your employment options, plans to open a practice, and professional relationships. Its enforceability depends on the agreement’s language, the employer’s legitimate interests, and the circumstances surrounding the restriction.

Jackson LLP reviews healthcare employment agreements and advises healthcare professionals on contractual terms that may affect a planned departure or new position.

If you are considering leaving a healthcare job, joining another practice, or opening your own, contact Jackson LLP to discuss a review of your agreement.

Free Attorney Consultation

Frequently Asked Questions About New York Non-Compete Agreements

Are non-compete agreements legal in New York?

Yes. New York generally permits non-competes that satisfy the state’s standards. Courts may reject restrictions that exceed legitimate business needs, impose undue hardship, or harm the public.

Possibly. The answer depends on the contract, the restriction’s scope, and the circumstances. Physicians should review applicable non-compete and other post-employment provisions before accepting another position.

New York does not set one maximum duration for all non-competes. Courts evaluate the length of a restriction in context, including whether it is reasonably necessary to protect legitimate business interests.

The answer depends on the agreement and applicable law. Non-compete and patient non-solicitation provisions have different purposes, and courts may consider patient choice and the public interest.

Yes. A review can identify restrictions affecting your next job, practice location, patient relationships, notice obligations, and financial responsibilities.

Reviews From Practice Owners

Scroll to Top